Goldstein on the Cartoon War

Identity Politics, Free Speech, and the Future of worldwide Liberalism, 2: a follow-up

From Islam Online:

Danish Muslim leaders warned on Saturday, February 4, of grave consequences if copies of the Noble Qur’an were burnt in a rally planned by Danish extremists to protest Muslim anger over cartoons mocking Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).

“All hell will break loose, if those extremists burn the Qur’an,” Raed Halil, the head of the European Committee for Defending Prophet Muhammad, told IslamOnline.net over the phone from the Danish capital Copenhagen.

“A female member of a racist party circulated a message calling for burning copies of the Noble Qur’an in Saturday’s march,” he said.

Note the bolded text, because it draws clear (if to be expected) lines of demarcation between the actions of the rival “protest” groups: the Danish protesters are “extremists” from “extreme-right”—many members of a “racist party”—while those outraged by the publishing of the cartoons in the first place (and who “protested” by burning flags, firebombing embassies, and—even here, through a spokesman, are issuing active threats of “grave consequences” and promises that “All hell will break lose” should counterprotests seek to address “Muslim anger”) are mere victims of some minor misunderstanding in the “new cultural battle over freedom of speech and respect of religions.”

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. Mark in Mexico on 04 Feb 2006 at 5:14 pm

    What really started the Muslim anti-cartoon rampag…

    As reported many places over the past few days, most recently here, there is a lot more to this Muhammed cartoon row than meets the eye. When Danish Imams who originally protested the cartoons could not drum up enough of the appropriate outrage and v…..

Comments

  1. MohammedCartoon wrote:

    http://mohammedcartoon.blogspot.com/ THis is where the cartoons are.

  2. MohammedCartoon wrote:

    If you are looking for the cartoons that were run in the newspapers they are at my website.

  3. CDR Salamander wrote:

    PBUH. Peas be upon him and everyone.

  4. Mark Mayam wrote:

    Frankly, if we’re going to tolerate “art” depicting Mary with feces, then we shouldn’t have a problem with feces-free pictures of Muhammed.

    –Chris

    cf http://www.mtholyoke.edu/offices/comm/csj/991008/madonna.html

  5. tunnaa wrote:

    hi everyone,

    i am tunnaa from turkey which is the most modern muslim country in the world. i am 30 years old, i born and grow up in this country, it writes muslim for my religion on my id card…

    well i can say that it’s a f… country and religion…

    i don’t like it, it has hate and no knowledge…
    that’s why i run away from religion…it’s terrible

  6. tunnaa wrote:

    also i want to say that i can’t leave the country because here government doesn’t give you passport if you don’t join army and fight for them and they say here is a democratic country…there is no way when there is muslim religion then there is no peace,humanity,freedom…